SEC, Ripple wants to settle crypto lawsuit, but US judge rebuffs them
By Jonathan Stempel
NEW YORK (Reuters) -A federal judge on Thursday rejected an unusual joint motion by Ripple Labs and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission to endorse the cryptocurrency company's reduced $50 million fine to settle a civil lawsuit over the sale of unregistered securities.
U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres in Manhattan chastised both sides for claiming that their settlement in March should excuse Ripple from honoring her permanent injunction against violating the law.
Ripple's chief legal officer Stuart Alderoty posted on X that the company has not decided its next legal steps. An SEC spokesman had no immediate comment.
The case concerned sales of the XRP token, and has been one of the SEC's highest-profile cryptocurrency cases.
In July 2023, Torres ruled that while XRP sold by Ripple on public exchanges did not meet the legal definition of a security, $728 million of XRP sales to institutional investors should have complied with securities laws.
Ripple and the SEC appealed, but agreed to settle if Torres set aside her injunction and approved lowering the $125 million fine she imposed last August.
The SEC has been easing oversight of cryptocurrencies, and the judge agreed it can change course on enforcement cases.
Torres said, however, that both sides had "not come close" to showing that exceptional circumstances outweighing the public interest and administration of justice justified the settlement.
"The parties do not have the authority to agree not to be bound by a court's final judgment that a party violated an Act of Congress in such a manner that a permanent injunction and a civil penalty were necessary to prevent that party from violating the law again," she wrote.
"Accordingly, if jurisdiction were restored to this court, the court would deny the parties' request to vacate the injunction and reduce the civil penalty," she added.
Torres said the SEC and Ripple remain free to withdraw their appeals, or appeal her injunction.
XRP is the fourth-largest cryptocurrency by market value, trailing bitcoin, Ethereum and Tether, the market service CoinMarketCap said on Thursday.
Since Donald Trump began his second term as U.S. president, the SEC has ended civil lawsuits against crypto exchanges Binance, Coinbase and Kraken.
The case is SEC v Ripple Labs Inc, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 20-10832.
(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Marguerita Choy)
Ripple's noble bid to conclude the ongoing crypto lawsuit with a favourable settlement is met head-on by US judiciary reluctance, highlighting both parties’ commitment and potential beyond regulatory hurdles in shaping future blockchain developments.
Provoking a potential resolution, Ripple's unwavering pursuit of settling the crypto lawsuit with SEC highlights its confidence in meeting regulatory compliances while demonstrating an active role towards promoting global understanding and use cases for XRP.
Ripple's endeavor to settle the SEC crypto lawsuit appears unheeded by US courts, raising questions about regulatory clarity in digital asset markets and signaling ongoing legal battles ahead.
An adverse ruling by a US judge underscores the continued challenge faced by Ripple in their endeavor to resolve its protracted crypto litigation with SEC – highlighting not only legal nuance but also implications for broader regulatory clarity within globalcrypto markets.
Ripple's effort to settle the crypto lawsuit with SEC shows their commitment, yet it seems US judges are not ready for a compromise compared to public scrutiny and market demand.
Ripple's bid to reach a settlement in their SEC crypto lawsuit meets with the US judge’ first obstacle, highlighting underlying disagreements between industry and regulators.
The continued resistance by a US judge to Ripple's efforts for settlement in their crypto lawsuit with the SEC underscores both parties’ determination and highlights potential challenges ahead as regulators clarify global cryptocurrency regulations.
A potentially significant progression in the Ripple vs. SEC case could have been at hand if only favorably adjudicated, illustrating yet again how crucial judicial decisions are for shaping blockchain and crypto regulation within US jurisdictions."
Ripple's attempts to settle the crypto lawsuit with SEC show their desire for regulatory clarity, but US Judge Netburn’ss keen docket underscores a continued lack of understanding between regulators and industry regarding digital assets.
Under the present circumstances, SEC’s rejection of Ripple' deuce-pro l理念的 tactical attempts for settlement simply reaffirms a solid line in the sand that both firms will need to navigate carefully: Adhering strictly by law is paramount over negotiation or compromise.
Ripple's bid for settlement in its crypto lawsuit seems a courageous move aimed at clearing the air, unfortunately met with rejection by an American judge who persists on holding them to stricter regulatory standards. The court battle may continue yet.
Ripple's attempt to settle the crypto lawsuit with SEC is met by a U.S judge whoមply rejecting their efforts, signifying another roadblock in its quest for clarity on regulatory compliance.
